Cheapest Andy's Frozen Custard Meals (2026)
The 9 cheapest items on the Andy's Frozen Custard menu, ranked by price — from value menu staples to the best deals, with calories where available.
#1 Ranked 2026
Vanilla Cone — $2.99
Splits & Specials · 280 calories · 6g protein
View Vanilla Cone details →Full Ranking — Top 9 Cheapest Meals
| Rank | Item | Price | Calories | Protein |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Vanilla ConeSplits & Specials | $2.99 | 280 cal | 6g |
| 2 | Dipped ConeCones & More | $3.99 | 360 cal | 7g |
| 3 | SundaeCustard | $4.49 | 420 cal | 8g |
| 4 | FloatCones & More | $4.99 | 380 cal | 7g |
| 5 | ConcreteCustard | $5.49 | 620 cal | 12g |
| 6 | ShakeCustard | $5.99 | 580 cal | 11g |
| 7 | Flavor of the MonthCones & More | $5.99 | 640 cal | 12g |
| 8 | Turtle ConcreteSplits & Specials | $6.49 | 700 cal | 13g |
| 9 | Banana SplitSplits & Specials | $6.99 | 720 cal | 13g |
How We Ranked These Andy's Frozen Custard Items
This ranking is computed automatically from the Andy's Frozen Custard menu in our structured database — every item is filtered and sorted by price, protein, calories, and value using structured data from official menu sources. Rankings update when the underlying menu data is refreshed. Prices are approximate national averages and may vary by location.
Cheapest Meals — FAQ
What is the cheapest thing on the Andy's Frozen Custard menu?
Are there cheaper options on the Andy's Frozen Custard value menu?
Allergen Notice: Menu items may contain or come into contact with common allergens including milk, eggs, wheat, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, fish, and shellfish. Always check with the restaurant directly if you have specific dietary needs or severe allergies. This information is provided as a reference and may not be complete.